A fee the Owner can follow is built bottom-up from the scope: tasks, hours by person, rates, subconsultants, expenses and escalation, each shown on its own line, then checked against your history from at least one other direction. When the Owner's reviewer can trace every dollar back to a task in the Scope of Services, negotiation is about scope, not about trust.
1. Start from the Scope of Services
List the phases and tasks in the same order and numbering as the scope in the agreement. If the Owner's RFP has a task list, use theirs. A reviewer who can lay your fee beside the scope, line by line, approves it faster.
2. Estimate hours by task and by person
For each task, decide who works on it and how much of their week it takes while it runs (see the utilization article). Hours follow: share of the week × 40 × weeks.
Check the total against something physical: hours per drawing sheet, hours per specification section, hours per meeting and submittal. Owners check these too.
3. Price the labor
Two common ways, depending on the Owner and contract:
- Billing rates. Each role has an hourly rate that already includes overhead and profit. Simple to read; common on hourly and lump-sum work.
- Cost plus fee. Direct salary cost × (1 + overhead rate), plus a negotiated fee for profit. Common with federal and many state and local agencies, which may audit the overhead rate.
Use one basis throughout. Monthly earned-value reviews later depend on actual cost being on the same basis as the budget.
4. Add subconsultants
Carry each subconsultant's proposal as its own line: geotechnical, survey, structural, electrical. Add a markup for managing them only if the agreement allows it, and show it separately.
5. Add expenses
Mileage, printing, shipping, permit and review fees. List quantities and unit rates, not just a lump sum. Some Owners allow a markup on expenses; pass-through items like permit fees usually carry none.
6. Add escalation for long jobs
If the work runs past your firm's next annual rate change, raise the rate on the hours that fall in the later year. Show it as its own line so the Owner can see it is a date effect, not a padded rate.
7. State the assumptions
The fee is only as clear as what it assumes. Write them down: number of review submittals, meetings, design alternatives, permits, construction-phase site visits. List what is excluded. When the scope changes later, these lines are what a change in services is measured against.
Worked example
A pump station design: Preliminary Design, Final Design and Bidding, about 20 months, with billing rates of $210 (project manager), $165 (project engineer), $120 (engineer in training) and $110 (CAD designer).
Hours by phase and role
| Phase | PM | Project engineer | EIT | CAD | Hours | Labor ($) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preliminary Design (30%) | 40 | 160 | 200 | 120 | 520 | 72,000 |
| Final Design (60/90/100%) | 60 | 240 | 360 | 400 | 1,060 | 139,400 |
| Bidding | 20 | 40 | 30 | 20 | 110 | 16,600 |
| Total | 120 | 440 | 590 | 540 | 1,690 | 228,000 |
Fee summary
| Line | Basis | Amount ($) |
|---|---|---|
| Labor | 1,690 hours at billing rates | 228,000 |
| Subconsultants | Geotechnical $18,000 + survey $12,000, plus 5% management markup | 31,500 |
| Expenses | Mileage 1,200 mi at $0.70 ($840) and printing ($600), plus 10% markup; permit fees $1,500 at cost | 3,084 |
| Escalation | 3% on hours after month 12: 40% of Final Design labor and all of Bidding | 2,171 |
| Total fee | 264,755 |
Rates, markups, the 3% raise and the mileage rate are illustrative. Use the ones in your firm's rate schedule and the Owner's agreement.
Each number traces back: the Owner can see that Final Design is 63% of the hours, that subconsultant markup is $1,500, and that escalation adds less than 1%. That is what "can follow" means.
Cross-check the fee from more than one direction
The bottom-up fee from the staffed schedule is the one you defend line by line. Before you send it, price the job at least one other way. If two methods land close together, you can be confident. If they don't, you have found something to look into.
| Method | Basis | Good for | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bottom-up (staffed schedule) | Tasks × people × weeks | The fee you negotiate and track against | Only as good as the task list; misses what you forgot |
| Hours per deliverable | Your firm's history: hours per drawing sheet, specification section, report, submittal | Catching hours that are light or padded | Needs records from similar jobs; a sheet of standard details is not a sheet of yard piping |
| Design fee as % of construction cost | Design fee ÷ estimated construction cost | A quick check against past jobs and the Owner's expectations | The construction cost is a guess before the design exists |
| Construction support as % of construction cost | Construction-phase fee ÷ construction cost | Sizing submittal review, RFIs, site visits and closeout | Contract duration and the contractor drive effort more than cost |
Cross-checking the example
- Per sheet. Preliminary and Final Design total 1,580 hours. Say the set is about 50 sheets, and your history for similar pump stations is 25 to 35 hours a sheet, all-in. That gives 1,250 to 1,750 hours. The bottom-up number falls inside the range.
- Percent of construction. Say the engineer's estimate is $3.5 million. The $264,755 fee is about 7.6% of it. Compare that with your past pump station jobs, and with any fee guidelines the Owner or funding agency publishes.
All of these figures are illustrative. Your own project history is the benchmark that counts.
Why construction value is a shaky basis on its own
- The cost isn't known yet. Before design, the estimate is a concept-level number that can easily be off by 30% or more in either direction.
- Size isn't effort. A small rehabilitation on a tight, live site can take more design per dollar than a larger new build on open ground.
- Prices move. A swing in construction prices changes the percentage without changing a single hour of design.
- It pays for cost, not value. A fee tied to construction cost rewards a more expensive design, which Owners notice.
Use the percentage as a sanity check, not as the fee.
When the methods disagree
Don't average them. Find out why. A bottom-up fee well below the per-sheet range usually means a missing task or light hours. One well above usually means extra scope the Owner didn't ask for, or an unusual project worth explaining in the assumptions.
Common ways a fee loses the Owner's trust
- One lump sum with no hours behind it.
- Tasks that do not match the scope's numbering.
- Markup hidden inside rates or subconsultant lines.
- Hours that do not fit the deliverable, like 40 hours a sheet on simple details.
- No assumptions, so every later change becomes an argument.
Do this in one tab. The Leroy PM Workbook runs this method with the schedule, staffing, fee and earned value tied together.
See the PM Workbook